On 16th November 2021 the National Resilience Committee of the British House of Lords published its report 'Are we ready? Building a culture of resilience see https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld5902/ldselect/ldresilience/79/7902.htm
Many organisations and individuals gave their opinions, I gave the historical perspective on how the police have helped communities leading up to and at the height of a time of crisis. The police in Britain have an enviable tradition of helping key industries when they face collapse from a disaster or pending disaster. The two periods I referred to were during the First World War when home food production was essential due to impending starvation and the police were released to help farmers to plough the fields and plant crops while managing the numerous other groups also sent into farming. I compared with with the COVID-19 pandemic when the police were released to drive ambulances at a time of huge increases in demand and ambulance staff becoming sick and having to take time off from work. You can see my responses and advice to the National Resilience Committee below:
History has a habit of repeating itself. The police in Britain since 1857 have the remit to manage the population while maintaining public approval for their work. In times of national disaster or approaching disaster, the strategies they used have been seen on at least two occasions: 1. during the First World War from March 1917 when the population faced starvation, and 2. similarly but updated for the social conditions in the COVID-19 pandemic from 2020.
The strategies the police used were in two stages:
- When a disaster is threatened, they work more closely with the population most likely to be affected. In 1915-16 under the threat of population starvation from blockading, they became closer to farmers by hand-delivering surveys and collected them after a few days; the surveys were to assess the potential for self-sufficiency in home food production and were mandatory to elicit government information on the numbers of workers on farms with the potential for conscription into the army and the numbers and types of animals to gauge the potential to feed the population.
By comparison in 2020 public criticisms of police handling of the pandemic by fining those refusing to stay at home, led the police to become closer to people who remained outside their homes by adopting a strategy of persuasion using the 4 Es (engage, explain, encourage, enforce), to engage in conversation those who remained outside, despite government instructions to stay at home https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/jt5801/jtselect/jtrights/1364/136406.htm This strategy was not only physical closeness to those breaking the law, but also attempting to understand their motivations by engaging them in conversation.
- When the disaster developed into a more acute phase, the police changed their tactics to move directly into the industry critical to sustain the population. In Spring 1917 this was into farming to help to plough and plant crops for an autumn harvest (see the numbers and locations of release in Table 1 below). They were again released in larger numbers in the autumn for harvest.
By comparison, in 2021 the police in needy areas across the UK moved directly into the ambulance service to drive ambulances, when the service was in fear of collapse from the huge increases in calls combined with ambulance staff becoming unwell or self-isolating. The police also helped to train ambulance drivers in some locations.
Table 1. Locations of police release in 1917
England | Approximate numbers | Scotland | Approximate numbers |
Cheshire | 25 | Glasgow | 90 |
Colchester | 4 | Motherwell | ? |
Norfolk | ? | Berwick, Roxburgh & Selkirk | 40 |
Birmingham | 100 | Greenock | ? |
Metropolitan Police | 150 | Edinburgh | 50 |
Birkenhead | 4 | Dundee | 40 |
Preston | 3 | Kincardineshire | ? |
Liverpool | ? | Ayr | 2 |
St Albans | 2 | Coatbridge | 4 |
Newcastle-upon-Tyne | 6 | Montrose | ? |
Sussex | ? |
|
|
In both eras during their presence in the industries under fear of collapse, the police acted to sustain the industry by working within it while managing the large numbers of staff recruited to help and managing potential disruption, for example in 1917 farm labourers in some areas threatened strike action for increased wages when they saw the incompetent soldiers placed on farms receiving higher wages while being expected to train them in farming work. Police working on farms also gave first-hand knowledge of progress to increase home food production under tight deadlines. During the COVID-19 pandemic feedback on the operation of the ambulance service in the areas most affected by driver shortages were helpful to monitor and plan these essential services.
On both occasions the skills needed for release into another industry was the key to success. The speed of release into the service under threat of collapse meant there was no time to train anyone. In 1917 Chief Constables chose those they released into agriculture because they had recently worked in farming, at this time around one third of those employed in police forces had an agricultural background. In order to competently help farmers to plough the land, skills in hand-ploughing were needed which was a skilled occupation. In 2021 those released into the ambulance service were skilled experienced drivers of ‘blue light’ vehicles, although some were given one day’s training in how to operate an ambulance.
The effects of police release into another industry in times of crisis was seen as hugely beneficial, they were a key organisation in increasing home food production, for example following the First World War, Prime Minister Lloyd George said in his memoires that ‘the food question ultimately decided the issue of this war’.
Therefore, speedily identifying police manpower with appropriate skills and releasing them into a service in fear of collapse to boost resilience is a long-established tradition. However, before the need for release is established, working more closely with the population likely to be most affected by disruption is a key skill; the police need to use the most effective method to create minimum disruption while pacifying and reassuring the public with both their presence and their verbal skills.
Police history shows they should be prepared to successfully deal with contentious situations, for example in 1917 farm labourers threatened or actual strike action, in 2021 physical and verbal abuse from the public.
Police management of the population today includes resilience training. As the lead organisation this should involve public, private, philanthropic and local organisations and communities. It should incorporate the ability to best cope with abuse, resistance, threats and attacks from the public, see https://phys.org/news/2021-06-reveals-true-impact-covid-police.html to increase resilience.
The police, in combination with other organisations in disaster management, should carefully document their learning from practice and actual events contemporaneously, with the reasons for decisions. They should store these organisational memories for easy access in future events to increase resilience.
Funding to carry forward decisions and manpower should be assured; this may need the appointment of champions to ensure no cuts to funding or expertise take place over the long-term.
Advice to The House of Lords Select Committee on National Resilience
- The police need to tell their stories of success in keeping the population safe during potential or actual disasters. This storyline can help their credibility with the public and foster a sense of pride within the service;
- The police should keep an up-to-date database of skills within the service so that immediate release into another essential industry in times of crisis can be made efficiently. As the lead organisation in Local Resilience Forums, they should persuade other core services to do likewise;
- Detailed records of activity and decisions in the build up to a disaster and during its peak need to be kept at the time of the occurrences and stored with easy access, particularly answering the questions ‘why’ decisions were made to allow institutional memory to be available in the next crisis, to learn the lessons of history and prevent mistakes recurring;
- Designated resources should be made available to capture institutional memory at the time of the operation of a disaster for use in future events and training;
- Champions need to be appointed to ensure long-term plans for resilience and the appropriate resources are maintained in the long term and not reduced after the event has passed into history;
- As the lead organisation in local resilience forums, the police need to keep up to date with the latest methods of persuasion in crisis situations, to convince the public of their legitimate authority and to allay panic.
- The police need to prepare for disasters by a wider range of practice exercises and scenarios than terrorism and flooding. As identified by HMICFRS in 2021 https://hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/publication-html/the-police-response-to-the-coronavirus-pandemic-during-2020/ health scenarios also need to be included.
- Records need to be kept of the results, findings and reasons for decisions from practice exercises and scenarios and ensure they are easily accessible, building up a history of best practice to increase resilience.
Summary
Knowledge is the most important tangible resource of any organisation, the police need to efficiently capture contemporaneously, store and make easily accessible knowledge of their past for future reference with the rationale for decisions to avoid future costly mistakes. They should value both documentary and oral forms of institutional memory for effective decision-making, learning, and to avoid repeated mistakes. Effective memory management supports decision-making, learning, and organisational identity. However, challenges such as amnesia, resistance to change, and the politics of storytelling must be addressed. The police should foster a culture that records history, encourages storytelling, and learns from both successes and failures.
